Chamber Toastmasters Inner Club Debates: Does Career Building Require Sacrifice?

On November 26, 2014, Chamber Toastmasters enjoyed their annual debates.

20141126_3364

Traditionally, Chamber debates are incentive, thought-provoking and tough.

20141126_3369

According to Toastmasters International:

A formal debate offers to the Toastmaster an outstanding opportunity to develop the three basic abilities that are the foundation of the entire Toastmasters program. It develops better listening, thinking, and speaking not only for participants but for spectators as well.

Participation in a debate develops your ability to make a quick response, present coherent arguments, and make a clear presentation of your views. Nowhere else can a Toastmaster find a more ideal method for learning competitive speaking in a “head-on” situation.

This time the subject for our business oriented Club was totally relevant:

Does Career Building Require Sacrifice?

The Affirmative team consisted of its captain Timur Berezhnoy (DTM), Vladislav Kisselev (VP PR), Yulia Poliakova, and Alexey Aleynikov.

20141126_3359

The Negative team was lead by Tetyana Kisyelova (VP Education, CC/CL). Other team members were Anastasia Timofeeva, Anna Zelenetska (Sergeant at Arms), and Maya Tavluy from the fellow ArtTalkers Club.

20141126_3360

The debates were led by Iryna Grygorieva (CC/CL) who is a brilliant speaker and leader and serves as the Club’s Treasurer.

20141126_3378

The Debates started with the statement of the Affirmative team captain, Timur Berezhnoy. He reinforced the definition of sacrifice as something you give away in order to get something more valuable. Therefore, every effort requires sacrifice of time and physical resources, so one works hard instead of enjoying a football game but then gains much more in terms of position, salary, achievements and opportunities.

20141126_3371

The Negative team captain, Tetyana Kisyelova, put emphasis on pre-requisites of a successful enterprise that don’t require painful loss, based on the example and principles of Jim Whitehurst, RedHat CEO. That is: be interested in everything, and you’ll get knowledge without being bored; build the team to work with smart and pleasant people together; finally, treat your job as a mission and feel the passion for what you are doing, and then you’ll enjoy it.

20141126_3376

Then came the time of questions and answers. The Negative team posed a tricky task to define where is the sacrifice for a boss who has never shown any trace of workaholism, yet being continously promoted due to excellent interpersonal skills. Yulia Poliakova responded that career development does not imply the extreme of leaving everything for the sake of a job, rather it is a natural balance of planning and prioritization.

20141126_3384

The Affirmative team asked how one could learn something without sacrificing his/her time on the subject. Anna Zelenetska replied that if you like what you learn, it’s not a sacrifice.

20141126_3386

Then the Negative team wanted some positive examples of sacrifice. Vladislav Kisselev pointed out that sacrifice is in very nature of all change and transformation, and a beautiful flower or butterfly is but a few positive outcomes of sacrifice, by a seed or a caterpillar, in these cases.

20141126_3390

The Affirmative team inquired of the way to achieve sacrifice-free career development, as if a question from a job interview on where do you see yourself in several years. Maya Tavluy has used the similar rhetoric as Yulia Poliakova to emphasize on the balance between the work you like and the things and people you love.

20141126_3387

The final word for the Negative team was taken by Anastasia Timofeeva. She disproved that anything could be regarded as sacrifice if you enjoy it, so it’s up to you to find the job you like, rather than practice sacrifice.

20141126_3401

The summary from Alexey Aleynikov from the Affirmative team was passionate, as he compares any work as a flame that, on one hand, hurts, but, on the other, shines.

20141126_3397

While the judge Maryna Gotovkina analyzed the debate’s speeches and arguments, a witty Table Topics session was conducted by Lilya Klyamar who addressed the same questions about career and sacrifice to the audience.

20141126_3365

At the end of the Table Topics, Lilya illustrated an insightful Oriental proverb about life priorities with the help of: tangerins, pasta, seeds, and water.

20141126_3411

The most convincing and well-structured answer was given by the club’s rookie Michael Rybak who received the people’s votes for the Table Topics session.

20141126_3431

The team who won the debates was also determined by the votes of all who were present. The majority voted for… Yes, career requires sacrifice. No suprise for the business community which the Chamber TM club claims to be. However, the battle was tough indeed, because, according to the judge’s feedback after the meeting, the Negative team presented stronger argumentation and more prepared defence for their point of view.

At the end, each participant has won a nomination from the judge.

20141126_3420 20141126_3421 20141126_3422 20141126_3423 20141126_3424 20141126_3425 20141126_3426

All in all, both participants and spectators enjoyed the show a lot.

20141126_3428

Here are some feedbacks from the teams:

Briefly: It was tough, breathtaking competition of two equal qualified teams.

In order to prepare for the debates we had to sacrifice our free time and energy, but our team’s pro-active attitude and efforts turned into such a sweet and remarkable victory.

Are you eager to participate in the debates next year? Start preparing now 🙂

Advertisements
Categories:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s